After a traumatic time with Harry Potter, I’ve been resisting further forays into kiddy fantasy. I’ve been the cat who desperately wanted the goldfish, looking at my wet paw in puzzled horror.
But then I got lured into the murky Pullman ocean by the Golden Compass film (it’s not a compass, it’s an alethiometer, dagnammit!) which was partly filmed in my (mainly) beloved Oxford. Though the brute of a film wasn’t all it could have been, some aspects of the story intrigued me. Like Iofur Raknison, I now longed for a daemon of my own. A budgie perhaps.
My fumble into this allegory-laden adventure started well. I wanted to know about Dust and daemons and find out what on earth the mysterious Lord Asriel was up to. I liked Lyra and her youthful exuberance, her cheeky foot-stomping attitude. I was even creeped out by the golden monkey.
But somewhere along the line, Northern Lights lost my interest. Maybe the noble polar bears were a step to far. Maybe it was the thick bog of fancy name detail which always goes in one eye and out the other and leaves every tenth word meaningless. Perhaps I should give up reading fantasy all together and stick to Stephen Fry and Danny Wallace. Perhaps, contrary to previous musings, I ++am++ an imaginative failure.
I’ve been thinking about it.
Something nagged at me all the way through this book, and I’ve finally figured out what it was. This is a grown-up book with a child protagonist. Far more intellectually demanding than Mr Potter and his merry little wizards, this is a book that touches on the real world and the things that we all wonder about: God, sin, hope and desire. The nature of the universe. And what we get is a through-the-eyes-of-a-child nothing-really-makes-sense outlook. Well, maybe it doesn’t. But stop letting the kids steal the limelight and give us grown-ups something to do? Please?
I ++liked++ Northern Lights. I read it all the way to the end and didn’t skip any dull bits (there were a few – mainly the polar bears). It confirmed my suspicions that the film neglected huge chunks of good stuff. But that’s all I can say. It wasn’t the revelation I was hoping for. I still want a daemon though.
Apologies to any polar bears.

